Not so fast, Rafale!
World’s media has just boarded the next flight to Brasília from Paris in a brand new Rafale. Let’s read the official communiqué of Sarkozy-Lula meeting:
Por seu lado, levando em conta a amplitude das transferências de tecnologia propostas e das garantias oferecidas pela parte francesa, o presidente Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva anunciou a decisão da parte brasileira de entrar em negociais com o GIE Rafale para a aquisição de 36 aviões de combate
On his turn, given the amplitude of transfer of technology proposals, assurances offered by the French counterpart, President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva announced the decision of the Brazilian counterpart to begin negotiation with GIE Rafale for purchase of 36 fighter aircrafts.
As Folha’s report explains, that statement only says Brazil is exclusively talking to France to buy some airplanes, both Sweden and the U.S. are in a temporary freeze. It’s crucial to highlight Brazilian Air Force (FAB) hasn’t yet delivered its own analysis on the three contenders: France’s Dassault Rafale, Sweden’s Saab Gripen NG, and U.S.’ Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornet.
Folha, in another reports, says Super Hornet is the dream aircraft for Brazilian Air Force pilots, but they are skeptical of American willingness to transfer technology. A O Estado de S. Paulo editorial says Super Hornet is the fighter chosen by FAB, criticizes Rafale price tag, failure on international bids.
O Estado de S. Paulo reports FAB High Command convened an extraordinary meeting, issued a press release saying bidding process isn’t over and both Gripen and Boeing will have a chance to submit their bids to FAB. Moreover, Folha is now saying the only way Dassault can win this bid is to substantially reduce Rafale unit price, which is 40% higher than Super Hornet. Lula’s Monday announcement also pissed off FAB top brass, while putting Brazil’s Defense Minister Nelson Jobim in hot water.
U.S. State Dept. says it’s fully committed to the technology transfer, and the White House quietly cheered expiration of the 30-day window in which the U.S. Congress can object to a Foreign Military Sale (more info about Boeing proposoal).
F-X2 isn’t dead yet!












